Amber,
I have both scenarios right now in properties I own. One property is set up as room rentals. In that situation, everyone has their own lease, pays their security deposit, and is responsible for any damage. They also have specific rules to follow in their lease for shared spaces within the house.
The other is a two-bedroom with roommates on the same lease. They have a shared responsibility for the unit. If one wants to move out, we’d create a new lease. In this situation, the two tenants found each other before renting the place and only qualified for the unit because it was their combined income.
Here are some pros and cons that I can think of with each approach.
Room Rentals (Separate Leases)
Pros
- Individual accountability for rent and damage.
- Simpler process if one tenant leaves.
- Specific rules for shared spaces can be enforced per lease.
- Can often charge more by the room than you can if you rent the entire unit out.
Cons
- Lots more drama. Guests, parking, shared areas, living habits. The headaches can really get out of control.
- More management (multiple leases, turnover).
- Usually less stable renters as people aren’t usually excited to be in a room rental for long.
For Joint Leases (Roommates on One Lease)
Pros
- Joint and several liability means all are responsible for the full rent and damages, making collection easier.
- Less drama because tenants often pre-screen each other and qualify with combined income.
- Less administrative work than individual leases.
Cons
- One roommate leaving can be complex (lease changes, re-qualifying).
- Security deposit disputes can be harder to resolve fairly.
- Less revenue as you usually can’t charge as much as you would with room rental
Summary
Sorry for the long post, but having done both, I’m trying to get out of room rentals and go to roommates on a joint lease. I also want them to apply and qualify together so they are, in part, committing to making a living together. The increased drama of individual room rentals is not worth it for me. I’d sacrifice the revenue for stability and sanity.
I’d love to know other people’s thoughts on the subject though. Any thing I missed in my pro/con list?
i agree. Text is more efficient communication way with tenant than Emails.
Can you integrate a Text communication way into the system instead of sending them emails? Not every tenant checks emails every minute but Text will pop out once it is sent out
Rajesh,
I appreciate the question.
I can confirm that TurboTenant does a soft credit pull on applicants’ credit history, which does not impact their credit score. The reason we selected to partner with TransUnion as the credit history provider is for precisely that reason, they allow a soft pull that doesn’t impact credit scores. I’d never want a renter penalized for applying to a property.
I can’t speak to this exact renter, but if you’d reach out to [email protected], we could investigate further.
Melissa,
I’m sorry to hear you’re not getting value out of the renter check-ins. Here is an article that speaks to why we created them and why landlords find them valuable. That being said if you wish to disable them please email [email protected] and we can turn them off for your renters.
Thanks for leaving your feedback and being a TurboTenant user!
I second this! I use an app/third party vendor (Grasshopper) and I can’t change the phone to my Grasshopper App because TurboTenant verification process won’t allow the call to go through (you have to select 0 for the call to go through)
I’d like to be able to just type in the rent amount as opposed to manually selecting every late payment box; I’d also like the option to mass select late payments to delete. (To give some background I have some older, less tech savy tenants who make cash payments at the bank and I have to manually record the payment. That’s not always done in a timely manner)
The forum ‘General’ is closed to new discussions and replies.